So that's it! I've read or tried to read 35 out of the 54 main series Horus Heresy novels, plus five Primarch series novels. I've divided them into three categories here: the novels I feel you must read if you're into this stuff, the ones I suggest you do read if the subject is of any interest to you, and the ones I would say don't read.
Must read:
Horus Rising
Legion
The First Heretic
Betrayer
Do read:
Galaxy In Flames
Flight of the Eisenstein
Mechanicum
A Thousand Sons
Nemesis
Fear to Tread
Shadows of Treachery
Scars
Vengeful Spirit
Path of Heaven
Tallarn
Titandeath
Alpharius: Head of the Hydra
Sanguinius: the Great Angel
Don't Read:
Battle for the Abyss
Fallen Angels
Deliverance Lost
Know No Fear
Unremembered Empire
Konrad Curze: The Night Haunter
**
After I finished Sanguinius, I took a bit of a break to collect my thoughts.
First of all, the Horus Heresy books were better than I expected. As I said in my very first post in this series, on Horus Rising, great literature this ain't. But it was definitely entertaining, more so than I had thought, even at times a bit emotional. So again, if you're into Warhammer at all, I really do recommend giving these books a shot.
Way back when I read False Gods, I talked about the way the Imperium in Warhammer used to be a 2000AD-esque parody dystopia, but these days are very clearly the good guys. Reading the whole series only reinforces this point. Nothing about this is satire, and the Emperor and the Imperium are very clearly the good guys, and Horus and the traitors are the bad guys. Sometimes there's a little bit more nuance than that, but then we go right back to very black-and-white good guys-bad guys tropes.
At worst, the series veers into leering misogyny and actual fascism; at best, there's positive representation for minorities. So in this sense, these books are very much a Games Workshop product. As I've said before, the company very clearly can't decide if they want to throw the bigots out of the fandom or dogwhistle to them.
**
From a fluff standpoint, so to speak, the Horus Heresy novels do a great job filling in a lot of background for basically everything to do with Warhammer 40,000. I now kind of have opinions and feelings about all of the legions, when before this reading project, I couldn't even have named all of them.
To adapt one of my favorite pieces of reasoning ever, the Iron Hands are the most boring and forgettable legion, which is a distinction the Ultramarines lack, making them officially the most boring of all legions.
So did we learn why the Horus Heresy happened?
Not really.
I mean okay, due to a Word Bearers plot, Horus got stabbed by a demon and went on a weird vision quest? Which somehow made fully half of all space marines suddenly hate the Emperor? No, to be honest, this is like Fallout 3 and 4 in that the main plot really doesn't make a whole lot of sense at all, but it's not really why we're here.
Now, some falls are very understandable. In First Heretic, the Emperor spectacularly humiliates Lorgar and the Word Bearers, and they go off to find gods that want to be worshipped. In Shadows of Treachery, we learned that the Night Lords were basically starting their own Curze Heresy. Then there's Angron and his World Eaters, not to mention the Emperor keeping everyone in the dark about his big secret project, which leads to Nikaea and sending the Space Wolves to attack the Thousand Sons.
So yes, it's called the Horus Heresy, but by the looks of things, the Emperor had at least four legions fully ready to rebel or in fact attacked by his loyalists without Horus doing anything. This leads to what must be the biggest theme of the whole Horus Heresy: Emps is a Really Shitty Space Dad.
**
To very briefly recap, Emps is an angry New Atheist who hates magic and the Warp, so he uses magic and possibly some kind of pacts with warp entities to make twenty* super-supersoldiers, the Primarchs. Each has a personality of their own and there's at least some notion that each of them represents some aspect of humanity or whatever. The Primarchs are then snatched up by the Chaos gods or something and scattered all over the galaxy.
Some of them end up in fairly benign environments, at least for the Warhammer 40,000 universe; they're adopted by some kind of parent (I think invariably father) figure, and grow up to be more or less decent people. Others end up in pretty terrible circumstances, like a cyberpunk dystopia where they become the Crow, a Mad Max planet where they're adopted by the Ayatollah of Rock and Rollah, or worst of all, Space Rome where they become a Spartacus who's bioengineered to be constantly angry.
Meanwhile, Emps sets out on the Great Crusade for Science and Rationalism, which slightly weirdly involves pretending that daemons and such don't exist, and he starts finding the Primarchs. Perhaps strangely for a New Atheist, Emps's method in dealing with his kids seems to be the Matthew Principle: the ones who had everything good are treated good, while the worse the world and situation they ended up in, the shittier Emps seems to treat them.
With some of the Primarchs, it's difficult to understand the whole thing at all. If you're an angry atheist who sets out to make up some guys, why do you then make one of them Theology Guy? And then when he goes and does theology, why is your solution to publicly humiliate him and his entire legion? Similarly, you hate magic, so you made up Magic Guy, and when you decide you now need to do a Super Secret Magic Project, you specifically refuse to tell Magic Guy, and then send your drunk furry enforcers to murder him. And all of that makes a lot more sense than the way Emps treats Angron. He even leaves Goth Guy on his own to sulk.
So yeah, the main overriding theme of the Horus Heresy is that Emps is a Shitty Space Dad, and if you want a single cause for the whole damn Horus Heresy, that's it. I suspect that this forms part of the appeal of the series: men can read and think about fatherhood and feelings if the dads and sons are wearing power armor in space.
**
I'm not done with this stuff yet, of course. There's the whole Siege of Terra series yet to come, and an entire sequel series to that called the Scouring is just getting started. And yes, I will be reading them. I bought the Siege of Terra books as they came out, and the first Scouring book is by Chris Wraight, whose work I've quite liked.
And I suppose that's my final word on the Horus Heresy novels: I've read 40 of them, and I'm going to read more. Part of the reason is that I've been reading about Space Marines and everything Warhammer since, I think, 1992, and I'm not going to stop now. The Warhammer 40,000 universe is such an impressive accretion of lore by now that it has a life of its own, entirely independent of what Games Workshop wants to do with it. And so far, the Horus Heresy novels have been a really good addition to that giant pile of lore.
Hell, they even gave Abaddon a personality.
*hail hydra


















































